The Supreme Court Feuds Over Death Penalty

death penaltyUPDATED:8:51 AM ET, Tue April 2, 2019

Controversy has been sparked over a recent execution of a Muslim inmate in Alabama which led to a rare public debate between the Supreme Court justices on how the death penalty should be enforced.

The justices are still divided and have not reached a compromise over the execution of Domineque Ray, a man who claimed that his religious rights were disregarded due to not being allowed to have an imam with him in the execution chamber back in February.

In early February, the conservative-oriented court couldn’t provide much reasoning regarding their decision to allow the execution of Ray to go forward. The Alabama penitentiary allows for a Christian chaplain to be in the room; however, officials blocked the imam, forbidding this request and claiming that prison employees could only be present in the chamber for security concerns.

However, it didn’t stop there. Another death penalty case involved the request for a Buddhist spiritual adviser last week, and the controversy continued since in this case the request was granted. These types of controversies are likely to intensify now that the addition of Justice Brett Kavanaugh has solidified the conservative bent of the court.

“The stakes do not get higher than they do in death penalty cases, and the arguments between the justices and rifts in the court may only get louder and deeper,” said Jessica Levinson, a professor at Loyola Law School.

She claims the court will likely move to the right and become more conservative in the coming years and “these three death penalty cases may demonstrate the court’s growing pains as it moves further away from the ideological center.”

Close Menu

Want the latest legal news
right to your inbox?

Sign up with your email below.

You have successfully subscribed to the newsletter

There was an error while trying to send your request. Please try again.

Proof Law Network will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.